Let’s talk about financial advisors and whether they’re worth the cost. The following is not investment advice, but rather life and money management.
The Simple Truth About Index Funds
For many investors, the core of their portfolio should be low-cost index funds. These funds track a specific market index (like the S&P 500) and have historically provided solid returns over the long term. The beauty? They require minimal effort and have very low expense ratios.
Why Paying 1% Per Year Can Hurt
Here’s the kicker: many financial advisors charge around 1% of your assets under management each year. That means if you have $500,000 invested, you’re paying $5,000 annually! Over decades, those fees can significantly eat into your returns.
Think about it:
- You can invest in index funds yourself: Platforms like Vanguard, Fidelity, and Schwab make it incredibly easy to buy and manage index funds.
- Index funds require minimal trading: The “buy and hold” strategy is a proven winner with index funds. You don’t need someone constantly adjusting your portfolio.
When an Hourly Fee Makes Sense
If you’re new to investing or feel overwhelmed, paying an advisor an hourly fee for guidance can be valuable. They can help you:
- Create a personalized financial plan: This includes determining your risk tolerance, time horizon, and investment goals.
- Set up your investment accounts: They can guide you through the process of opening and funding accounts.
- Choose appropriate index funds: An advisor can help you select funds that align with your plan.
The most important thing is not to KEEP paying them. Find an hourly advisor, set it up once, and forget it. Otherwise, here’s some actual investment advice to save that 1% – pick a target date fund (date you will retire, die, buy a house, whatever), and stick 100% of your money there. Done. Simple. Take the 1% I just saved you and go on a trip.
The Biggest Advantage of a Financial Advisor: Emotional Coaching
Here’s the real reason some people benefit from a financial advisor: behavioral guidance.
Markets go up and down. It’s inevitable. When the market crashes, it’s easy to panic and sell your investments at a loss. A good advisor can act as your voice of reason, reminding you of your long-term plan and preventing you from making emotional decisions. There’s a reason dead people make the best investors – they don’t panic.
If you’re one of the people that panic sold in early 2008, or in March 2020 as markets collapsed, then and only then do I advise the 1% fee, as you’ll surely lose more than that trying to time the market.
So, Who Really Needs a Financial Advisor?
- Investors who lack discipline: If you know you’re prone to emotional investing, an advisor can be invaluable.
- High-net-worth individuals: Those with complex financial situations (estate planning, tax optimization, etc.) may benefit from professional advice.
- People who simply don’t want to manage their own money: Some people are happy to delegate this responsibility, even if it costs more. <--if you're one of these, I'd be happy to charge you a few thousand dollars a year to stick money into index funds! :-)
The Bottom Line
For many investors, especially those starting out, paying a hefty annual fee to invest in index funds is unnecessary. Educate yourself, create a plan, and utilize low-cost platforms. However, if you struggle with emotional investing or have complex financial needs, an advisor can provide valuable support – just be sure to understand how they charge and what services they offer.
Leave a Reply